Is It Worth Fixing a Blown Head Gasket? How to Decide
Should I fix it?
Is it worth fixing a blown head gasket? How to decide
It is worth fixing a blown head gasket when the engine still starts and runs, the part that caused it can be fixed, and the rest of the car is worth keeping. How you fix it decides the rest: a shop replacement runs $2,000 to $7,000, and sealing the gasket with the head on costs far less.
We are the experts in cooling systems. We find what caused the failure, not only fix the gasket. Here is how to decide before you spend a dollar, in words a driver and a mechanic can both use.
Four questions that decide it
- Is it really the head gasket? Do a block test before anyone sells you a repair. Most auto parts stores lend the tester, and the fluid costs about $10. A shop charges around $35 to $50. Question any diagnosis made without a test. Dave Whitmer, our field technician, shows how: How to do a block test.
- Does the engine still start and run? The pistons push 100 to 200 psi or more against the gasket on every stroke, so a breach grows every time the engine runs. While it still starts and runs, it can be sealed with the head on. Once it will not start, that choice is gone.
- Do you know what caused it? Most head gaskets blow because a cooling system part failed first: a stuck thermostat, a weak water pump, a clogged radiator, a fan that does not come on. Leave that part in the car and any repair goes the same way as the old gasket.
- Is the rest of the car worth keeping? Look past the gasket: the transmission, the body, rust, and anything else that will need money soon. If the gasket is the only problem and the rest of the car is in good shape, the repair makes sense.
More on how to tell if your head gasket is blown.
Your three choices
- Replace the gasket at a shop. The cylinder head comes off, a machine shop checks it for flatness, and it goes back on with a new gasket. Labor is the biggest part of the bill. Expect $2,000 to $7,000, more if the head is warped, and many shops will not quote the job at all; they offer an engine instead.
- Seal it with the head on. Thermalweld seals the breach from inside the cooling system while the engine runs. No parts come off. The antifreeze is flushed out with plain water first, heater core included, because Thermalweld does not mix with antifreeze. Kits by engine: head gasket repair cost.
- Sell it as is. A car with a blown head gasket still has value to a mechanic who can repair it, or to a buyer of damaged cars. Weigh that offer against what the car is worth running.
The math most owners do
One common rule of thumb: replace the gasket only if the car is worth at least double the cost of the repair. On a $2,000 to $7,000 shop job, that means a car worth at least $4,000 to $14,000. On an older, high mileage car, the shop bill can be more than the car is worth.
Dave Whitmer puts it this way: “At 190,000 miles you’re not going to put $7,000 into a head gasket. A Toyota can go 300, 400,000 miles.”
Sealing it with the head on changes that math, because you are no longer weighing the car against a teardown.
When sealing it is not the answer
- It will not start, or will not turn over. The repair works while the engine runs. If it will not turn over, it may be hydrolocked; do not keep cranking it.
- The dipstick reads five inches or more over the full mark. That can point to a cracked block. Call us before anything goes in. See milky oil under the oil cap.
- It keeps overheating from a part nobody has fixed. Fix that first, or the new seal fails the same way.
- Coolant pours out of the tail pipe. Some engines are too far gone: Head gaskets that are too far gone.
In those cases, selling it as is can be the better call. Tell us what you see first, and we help you sort it out.
Is fixing a blown head gasket hard?
Replacing one is. The cylinder head comes off, and the job is difficult even for someone who knows engines. Sealing one takes no teardown: flush the antifreeze out, treat it exactly as the easy repair instructions say, and call tech support with any question along the way.
Already tried a sealer that did not work?
Where other products failed, we help you fix it. Before anything else goes in, call us.
Free unlimited tech support from the people who make it
Not sure it is worth it? Call (844) 796 7968 with the engine, the mileage and what the shop quoted. You talk to the people who make Thermalweld, as often as you need, free. Nobody else in the industry offers that. Thermalweld is BBB accredited and A+ rated.
We are saving livelihoods one blown head gasket at a time.
For mechanics and repair shops
Your customer just heard $2,000 to $7,000 and is ready to sell the car. Block test it, find the part that caused it, and quote both: the teardown, and sealing it with the head on. The job that would have walked out the door stays with you, and so does the customer. Our tech support is on the phone whenever the job gets tough. Unheard of in the industry. Nobody else comes close.
Mechanics: your first bottle is free. So is the unlimited tech support. thermalweld.com/technicians
Need a mobile mechanic? We find one for you.
Call (844) 796 7968 and tell us where the car is. At our cost, we call mobile mechanics in your area, qualify a well reviewed one for your job, and back them with free, unlimited tech support from start to finish. We know of no other head gasket brand that does this. How we find your mechanic
Quick answers
Is it worth fixing a blown head gasket on an old car?
It can be. On a high mileage car a shop replacement can cost more than the car is worth, so look at the rest of the car and at sealing it with the head on. If the engine starts and runs and the cause gets fixed, an old car can stay on the road.
Is fixing a blown head gasket expensive?
A shop replacement runs $2,000 to $7,000, mostly labor, and more if the head is warped. A block test to confirm it costs about $10. Sealing it with the head on costs far less; kits by engine are on the head gasket repair cost page.
Should I fix a blown head gasket or sell the car?
Fix it if the engine starts and runs, the cause can be fixed and the rest of the car is sound. Selling it as is makes more sense if it will not start, the block may be cracked, or the rest of the car needs more than it is worth. Call us before you decide.
Is it hard to fix a blown head gasket?
Replacing one is hard, because the cylinder head comes off. Sealing one with the head on takes no teardown: flush the antifreeze out, treat it as the instructions say, and call tech support with any question.
What happens if I do not fix a blown head gasket?
It gets worse. The breach grows every mile, the coolant loss grows with it, and one day the engine will not start. If the temperature gauge climbs, pull over and shut it off. See can you drive with a blown head gasket.
More answers
- Head gasket repair cost
- Can a blown head gasket be fixed without replacing it?
- Blown head gasket symptoms
This page is a guide, not a diagnosis. Call (844) 796 7968 with your engine, mileage and symptoms.
