Head Gasket or Water Pump? How to Tell Which One Failed
Is it my head gasket?
Head gasket or water pump? How to tell which one failed
A bad water pump most often leaks coolant at the front of the engine, and it can whine or let the engine overheat. A blown head gasket loses coolant inside the engine, with no leak you can see, and can bring white smoke, bubbles in the reservoir or oil in the coolant. A block test, which checks the coolant for combustion gas, tells you which one it is.
We are the experts in cooling systems. We find what caused the failure, not only fix the gasket.
Safety first. Never open the radiator cap or the pressure cap until the engine has cooled completely. Check the pump and its pulley with the engine off and cool, and keep hands clear of the belts and the fan. If the gauge climbs toward red, pull over when it is safe and shut the engine off.
What the water pump does
The water pump moves coolant through the engine and the radiator. On most engines it sits at the front, turned by the serpentine or timing belt. Under its shaft is a small weep hole: when the seal inside starts to fail, coolant shows there first. Slight seepage on a new pump can be normal; a wet trail is not.
Signs it is the water pump
- A puddle of coolant under the front center of the car after it sits.
- Drips or a crusty coolant trail at the weep hole or on the pump housing.
- A whine, growl or grinding noise from the front of the engine, which can get louder as you accelerate: a worn pump bearing.
- A wobble or play in the pump pulley.
- The engine runs hot with no leak at all, because the pump no longer moves the coolant.
Signs it is the head gasket
- The coolant level keeps dropping with no leak in sight.
- White smoke from the exhaust, with a sweet smell.
- Bubbles in the reservoir with the engine running.
- Oil in the coolant, or milky oil on the dipstick.
- A new water pump did not cure it: the engine still runs hot or uses coolant.
Both can make the engine overheat. Most pump failures show on the outside: a leak, a noise or a loose pulley. Coolant that disappears with no leak in sight points at the gasket, and a block test confirms it.
When a water pump looks like a head gasket
On some engines the water pump sits behind the timing cover. A leak there can put coolant into the oil with nothing showing outside, and milky oil is also a head gasket sign. So run a block test and call us before you buy anything. More on milky oil under the oil cap.
Can a bad water pump cause a blown head gasket?
Yes. When the pump stops moving coolant, the engine overheats, and that heat can warp the cylinder head and blow the gasket. That is why we look for the cause on every blown head gasket. Most head gaskets blow after a cooling system part failed first: a stuck thermostat, a weak water pump, a clogged radiator or a fan that does not come on.
Four checks, cheapest first
- Read the coolant level cold. Park on level ground and check it each morning before the first start. A level that holds points away from a leak at the pump or the gasket.
- Look at the pump with a flashlight, engine off and cool. Follow any wet trail back to its start: the weep hole, the housing, a hose or the radiator.
- Check the pulley, engine off. Push it side to side by hand. There should be no play; play points to a worn bearing.
- Pressure test, then block test. A cooling system pressure test makes a small outside leak show itself. If the system holds and the level still drops, run a block test. Most auto parts stores lend the testers; the block test fluid costs about $10, and a shop charges around $35 to $50. Dave Whitmer, our field technician, shows how: How to do a block test.
More on how to tell if your head gasket is blown.
Fix the cause, not only the symptom
A leaking or noisy water pump is replaced, with its gasket or seal. Ask whether its drive belt should be replaced too. A water pump is not a Thermalweld job.
When the block test shows combustion gas and the engine still starts and runs, a blown head gasket can be sealed with the head on. Thermalweld seals the breach from inside the cooling system while the engine runs. It does not mix with antifreeze, so the system is flushed with plain water first. Every step is in the easy repair instructions. More on whether a blown head gasket can be fixed without replacing it.
If a failing pump caused the overheating, it gets replaced too. Seal the gasket and leave the cause, and the engine runs hot again.
Free unlimited tech support from the people who make it
Not sure if it is the pump or the gasket? Call (844) 796 7968 with the engine, the mileage, where you see coolant and how much you add. You talk to the people who make Thermalweld, as often as you need, free. Nobody else in the industry offers that. Where other products failed, we help you fix it. Thermalweld is BBB accredited and A+ rated.
We are saving livelihoods one blown head gasket at a time.
For mechanics and repair shops
Before you quote a head gasket on an engine losing coolant, put a light on the weep hole, check the pulley and pressure test it cold. Before you sell a water pump on an engine losing coolant with no outside leak, block test it running. A dropping level and a positive block test on an engine that starts and runs is the job Thermalweld was built for. Our tech support is on the phone whenever the job gets tough. Unheard of in the industry. Nobody else comes close.
Mechanics: your first bottle is free. So is the unlimited tech support. thermalweld.com/technicians
Need a mobile mechanic? We find one for you.
Call (844) 796 7968 and tell us where the car is. At our cost, we call mobile mechanics in your area, qualify a well reviewed one for your job, and back them with free, unlimited tech support from start to finish. We know of no other head gasket brand that does this. How we find your mechanic
Quick answers
Is it my water pump or my head gasket?
If coolant shows at the front of the engine, or the pump whines or wobbles, suspect the pump. If the level keeps dropping with no leak, or you see white smoke or bubbles, block test for the head gasket.
Can a bad water pump cause a blown head gasket?
Yes. A pump that stops moving coolant lets the engine overheat, and that heat can warp the head and blow the gasket. Stop driving when the gauge heads for red.
What are the first signs of a bad water pump?
Coolant at the weep hole, a small puddle under the front of the car, or a whine from the front of the engine. Some fail inside with no leak and the engine runs hot.
Can a water pump leak look like a head gasket leak?
It can. On some engines the pump sits behind the timing cover and can leak into the oil, so milky oil can be either. Block test and call us.
How can I tell if my water pump is bad without removing it?
With the engine off and cool, check the weep hole with a flashlight, follow any coolant trail and push the pulley for play. A noise while it runs points at the bearing.
More answers
- Blown head gasket symptoms
- White smoke from the exhaust and losing coolant
- Can you drive with a blown head gasket?
- Head gasket repair cost
This page is a guide, not a diagnosis. Call (844) 796 7968 with your engine, mileage and symptoms.
